Water and We People

Critical Views about Water Management

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

De-silting of Lakes

Now a days there is a great demand for de-silting of lakes. The stated aims are - increase in storage capacity, removal of infected soil layer, etc. Such demand is more heard for urban lakes like Fateh Sagar and Pichola of Udaipur, Rajasthan, India. Public, in general, remains in favour of such demand feeling that it will improve the health of Lakes. Media also highlights such demand.

In my view, detailed studies need to be carried out before taking up such work and proper planning is also necessary so that adverse effects of such action are nullified.

First of all the existing storage capacity needs to be checked in comparison to the average inflow and if the present storage capacity of a particular lake is more than the average inflow then there is no need of de-silting. In case the average inflow is found more than the present storage capacity, then it has to be checked whether the storage capacity can be increased by raising the full tank level of the lake and whether a new lake can be constructed in the up-stream side. It is a well known fact that raising full tank level of an existing lake or constructing a new lake is always cheaper than increasing the storage capacity by excavation in the bed of lake as only earthen embankment or concrete/masonry dam is to be constructed in which lesser quantities are involved than that in excavation.

The second issue is this that for removal of contamination, silt clearance can not help much because it is practically impossible to completely flush the top soil of whole bed of the lake submergence. For such purpose, fish culture, algae growth, etc. are better alternatives.

In case, it is finally decided to de-silt a lake, efforts should be made to give the work by temporary lease of the area to be de-silted as the excavated silt is of great value as organic manure, ingredient for brick and tile making etc. and the cost of excavation is generally less than the market value of excavated silt.
If interested to read more, kindly see my detailed article "Conservation of lakes - Myths and realities of de-silting" as Guest Post at www.indiawaterportal.org/post/11646